mlm, network marketing, ebay, online auctions, affiliate marketing

Work At Home Ideas For Women | Home Base Businesses for Women

Work At Home Ideas For Women | Home Base Businesses for Women header image 2

Online Business Or Brick & Mortar? How Do You Choose?

June 27th, 2008 · 25 Comments

(Note!! Everyone that posts will be entered into

a random drawing for a $25 Amazon Gift Certificate!)

Okay, you’ve made the big decision to go the entrepreneurial route - you have finally decided that J-O-B really does stand for ‘just over broke’ - but do you launch a business online (is anyone really making money there?) or do you go the ‘real world’ route and open up a real land based business (yikes! the start up costs!)

This is a question that I get asked all of the time - and it’s a tough one for most people to answer.

For myself, it’s not so tough because after 2+ decades of self employment, I have been on both sides of the fence. I have had several brick and mortar businesses, I have had the ‘corner office’ jobs in the corporate world, and for the past decade have been working from home, running a growing network of websites as well as a consulting firm.

In my brick and mortar businesses, I had massive overhead and employees. I had to be someplace at a specific time pretty much every day - and if we weren’t open - we weren’t making money. I was successful - and miserable.

So, long before the internet came along, I was looking for a money making strategy that would let me have a more flexible lifestyle. I have to admit that I am a non-conformist - I love to travel, and am inclined to work better at 3am than 3pm….

I started down the mail-order path, which was definitely better because at least I could pretty much work whenever I wanted to and where ever I wanted to. But there was still the tedium of fulfilling orders, and I had to check into the PO Box at least once a week….which shouldn’t have been all that much of a bother but well, it was.

The internet came along and I dove in. I have been online and full time working from home with either web based businesses or consulting with web based businesses since 1994. I have had ups and downs as with any business - but overall, I would not trade it for anything. In 1999, I moved from California to Cincinnati, Ohio - missed one working day! Now, between my Blackberry and my MacBook - and WiFi! - I can work from almost anywhere!

And I do a lot of different things - I strongly believe in the ‘multiple streams of revenue’ approach. My consulting firm brings in revenue, my sites sell tangible products, affiliate products, my own ebooks, and then there is revenue from the various ad programs on all of the sites as well.

I am no techie - I know enough html to get by, but with blogs, you don’t even need to know that, although it is helpful, I will admit. But I taught myself by searching Google whenever I had a problem.

The point is - from my perspective, the web is such a great place to start a business that I can’t imagine having a brick and mortar business anymore.

BUT - I have friends who cannot imagine working from home, and being online so much.

SO - here’s the questions: What was the driving factor in your decision: online business vs brick and mortar? And, do you ever regret the decision - or plan to make the change to the other model anytime?

Stumble it!

Tags: Work At Home Ideas For Women - Start Your Own Business

25 responses so far ↓

  • 1 Lisa // Jun 28, 2008 at 12:23 pm

    I made the leap about 5 years ago to open a mall shop - my life long dream…at least that was what I thought. I live in an area that was hit by the first wave of recession, and now most of the mall is closed - and I a cannot get out of my lease without serious financial repercussions. So I am making enough to cover expenses etc but not enough to really cover my living costs. It’s a nightmare.

    I am opening a store online using the same product resources that I use for my store - at least if the online business slows down I won’t have this massive overheard. But the bottom line is I won’t have to sell as much to make the same profit either!

  • 2 Melody, aka The Netlady // Jun 28, 2008 at 12:26 pm

    That’s was my hard learned lesson, too, Lisa - and online you can open additional ‘niche’ stores with a minimal investment and easily target new markets.

    The internet has made it so much easier for anyone to become an entrepreneur - and there are tools today to make the process possible for virtually anyone.

    Personally, I love the web, and find the opportunities it offers amazing!

    Melody

  • 3 Jackie Johnson // Jun 28, 2008 at 2:26 pm

    I am a former HR Director and made a decision to resign from corporate america to focus on my home based health and wellness business. I quit in January and everything is going well. I have almost replaced my big corporate salary. Everyone will always buy skin-care, make-up, vitamins and aromatherapy, colon cleanse. Network marketing is a viable alternative to making a residual or replacement income.
  • 4 admin // Jun 28, 2008 at 3:22 pm

    Jackie - I totally agree with you regarding network marketing - it’s a very viable way to build a business while you are still working in the corporate world, too - it’s allowed a lot of women (including myself!) to make the transition relatively risk free.

    I also learned what I consider the most important business lesson of my life with MLM - the importance of RESIDUAL INCOME!! There are lots of ways outside of network marketing to earn residual income - but 99% of all that I do today is based on the potential of residual income.

    Jackie - you should head over to Womensnet.netand submit your profile for the Women in MLM Showcase!

    Melody

  • 5 Elizabeth // Jun 28, 2008 at 5:34 pm

    In my current position, I’m lucky to have the best of both worlds.

    After two grueling years, I left a job in hurricane recovery. The pay was great but that came at a huge emotional expense to me and my family. I decided last October to turn my 6 year hobby into a full-time business.

    I handcraft luxury toiletries-soap, lotions, body mists, lip balm, and feature a sugar scrub made with sugar grown on our plantation.

    I have an online presence with my store, and, while not technically brick and mortar, I have a wonderful indoor spot at a weekly market located in our vibrant downtown historic district. I usually only sell on Saturday but if I choose, I can sell during the week as well. My only cost is the fee for the day.

    The market affords me the opportunity to drive traffic to my website. I have a lot of customers who will order online, then pick up their orders at the market. They also use the website to purchase and ship gifts to their friends and family who do not live in the area.

    In the near future, I’ll be moving my operation from my home to a studio/retail store owned by a well-known stained glass artist. Even though I’ll have a retail spot, I still plan on selling at the market as it’s been very good to me so far.

  • 6 Elizabeth // Jun 28, 2008 at 5:53 pm

    Forgot to mention that I have a sign up sheet for my newsletter at my booth each week. My newsletter goes to two audiences: those who have registered as customers on the website, and those that just want to receive the newsletter. In each newsletter I point out that if one becomes a registered customer, one will receive a gift certificate good for your first online order. Again, incentive for driving traffic to the website.
  • 7 admin // Jun 28, 2008 at 8:45 pm

    Elizabeth - Sounds like you have a wonderful combination with your new business. I love the way you have combined the online orders with the market pick-up. You are giving your customers the convenience of online ordering but they still have the personal interaction with you as the business owner!

    Kudos for a great biz model!

    Melody

  • 8 Linda @ A4SB // Jun 28, 2008 at 10:04 pm

    In these days of soaring gas prices, knowledge of brick and mortar overheads, layoffs looming due to our economy, and technology based Accounting Software…… these were most of the major reasons I selected to work from home and promote my business thru the internet.

    I have over 20 years experience climbing the corporate ladder in the Financial Accounting realm and I, like many, have joined the new wave of those working from home.

    Today’s Accounting software and technology makes it easy for me to work with a client remotely via the net or on the phone. When I do spend time traveling its to meet with a client for the initial consultation or conducting staff training sessions, networking at various functions like the Chamber of Commerce or even conducting speaking engagements about the ways to avoid the high rate of failure small businesses endure.

    I Vote for Working from Home and conducting the greatest majority of my work over the internet. I too love to work at odd hours, like 3-6 a.m. and its easy to take a quick power nap if the workload is heavy. I look forward to hiring professional accounting associates in cities around the US and we will all be connected via the internet.

    The days of brick and mortar are over for me. Thank you for the opportunity to cast my vote.

  • 9 Kris // Jun 29, 2008 at 8:00 am

    Two years ago, after getting injured at work, I decided that I needed more income so I decided to start a business. I decided that an internet business was the best route for me and have never regretted it. Currently, I sell on Ebay, but I treat it as a business so I have many accounts with major companies and sell their products in new condition. I had spoke with several small business owners in the area and found that they are “tied” to their brick and mortar store daily. With my internet store, as long as I have computer access, I am free to leave the house and shop, run errands, and take my kids where they need to go. An added plus, I also no longer pay for child care and am more involved in their lives than I ever was. Also, I find that my sales are greater because I ship all over the world. I have access to a larger customer base by way of the internet. Currently, I am developing my own website which I work on a little at a time. The only drawback thus far is that I must continually check the internet to see if I have any questions about my products, but I still feel that the internet is the way to go.
  • 10 sidnee // Jun 30, 2008 at 12:07 pm

    Hi there Melody, great article!

    Recently i’ve stumbled upon a revolutionary ‘Business-in-a-Box’ system in a Free eBook, it has helped me to make some money since and i think you might be interested. It’s very new, you may want to write a review to share with readers if you find it useful :)

    (Instant download the Free eBook through my link, no opt-in required!)

    Warmly,
    sidnee

  • 11 Mattie // Jul 2, 2008 at 7:39 pm

    Although there’s something to be said for face-to-face client service, the internet opens the entire WORLD to our businesses!

    I too have worked in several successful businesses, both self created and MLM, and believe some niches require the brick & mortar approach. There will always be that audience who loves the interaction and personal service that can only be gained with brick & mortar.

    Overall, regardless of the high gas prices (which are hurting many, many lives), people like the convenience of the Pick - Pay - Post Office Delivery capability of the internet.

    Personally, I prefer the internet. The ability to reach a much wider audience is so appealing.

    And the overhead is ALOT cheaper!

  • 12 oc hometheater // Jul 5, 2008 at 8:07 am

    well , surely there are tons of opportunities available and this is freakin genius. The world is going to change in next 10 years .
  • 13 Melynn // Jul 5, 2008 at 10:58 am

    I’m kind of straddling the fence on this one at the moment. My business is still very new and far from supporting itself (or me!) So I’m still stuck in my dreary office job while also trying to get this thing off the ground. I do have a website but it hasn’t proved to be very lucrative yet. Because I’m a Pastry Chef, folks tend to want a shop to come into in order to see the product first hand and maybe score a few samples before they purchase. I’m no where near having the capital to quit my job and open a shop, although that’s my dream, so for now I’m renting kitchen space by the hour as I can and fulfilling orders as they come in either by word of mouth or via the website. I’m also selling at Farmer’s markets here and there. That helps a lot. It’s hard to choose. I would love it if my website were enough to pull this thing off the ground and get it flying, but it’s difficult to sell food products that way.
  • 14 Hypnotist // Jul 18, 2008 at 9:19 am

    I’ve worked at home — and absolutely loved it. I sold eye glass frames for a (now defunct) company. The money was great — I really hustled. Sales is a numbers game, the more calls you make, the more success you have. I live in Los Angeles, and was given a list (phone book size) of Opticians and Opthalmalogists in the South. I worked the heck out of that list - and was very successful with my work until the owners tried to take the business public.
    Now, I have a hypnotherapy practice. I service my clients out of a office filled with a plethora of (traditional) medical practitioners. The only time I spend at the office is for appointments — my calls are forwarded to my home or cell phone.
  • 15 Des // Jul 22, 2008 at 7:24 pm

    What drives me, to want to work at home is, the fact that I have never been able to conform. I have a family, and I want to enjoy life.
  • 16 Carol Thompson // Jul 23, 2008 at 11:55 am

    I decided to start an online business because the start-up cost was a lot less than a brick and mortar business. My online business is a legal forms and document preparation service. I have never regretted going this route and the possibilities with this are endless. This business allows me the creativity and flexibility that I might not otherwise have if I had opened a brick and mortar business. I enjoy what I do and to me that is something that is priceless.
  • 17 Sonograher // Jul 26, 2008 at 1:04 am

    All these stories and comments give me great encouragement. I have worked in healthcare, long stressful hours & taking call for 34 years. I’m so ready to step back from the stress and, as Des says, conformity. Over the last year, I have given much thought to an internet business, high end and not your every day run of the mill baby
    items. I’ve looked into someone to build my website. This week I was given the opportunity to buy an established business of entertainment ultrasound. You know, you show Mom & Dad the baby, take pictures, CDs, DVDs…the works in a soothing, pampering atmosphere. No actual diagnostic scans are done at all. This is what I have done & loved for years. I’m good at it!! Now the question: Stay at home with internet business vs established brick & mortar with greater financial risks, but also greater
    financial potential. Help!!!! Some of you savy girls must surely have been in a similar situation
    at one timeor the other. Advice? Gems of info?
  • 18 Kass // Jul 29, 2008 at 12:49 pm

    Well…getting the ball rolling on my own website that combines both of my passions. Because the website isn’t up and running yet and we haven’t nailed down the $$ potential (the niche market is surely there), I’m still slaving away in a corporate environment and miserably commuting every day. You all give me hope that at some point I’ll be able to run the site full time and get to spend more quality time with my toddler…

    PS - Any tips?

  • 19 ladybugs // Jul 29, 2008 at 7:26 pm

    Well..I have taken the plunge and have my website up and running and am now still trying to figure it all out!! It has been quite educational so far, but I am hoping it takes off as I now longer enjoy my “chosen career”. I want to be able to work when I want and where I want and enjoy my family and life!! I am hoping to have several websites with different niches. Say a prayer for me!!
  • 20 lilaclady // Jul 29, 2008 at 10:58 pm

    I want to offer you a few thoughts of mine.
    Something you should know first: there are two different things available for you: work from home and home based business. They are two absolutely different things. Work from home is something like a typist or virtual assistant or medical billing specialist - when you are actually employed by somebody and you are paid a fixed salary or hourly wages for your services.
    Another thing is a home based business. In this case you are becoming a business owner and your income potential increases, but you actually have to be involved in a decision-making process.
    I can’t advise you on work from home, but if you are asking about a home based business I might be able to give you some food for thought.
    In today’s world Internet has become a great vehicle to market goods and services and has allowed a lot of businesses to reach larger customer groups.
    The Internet has also created a concept of a “Internet marketer”: a person who markets products and services via the Internet.
    So, in many cases, “home based business” means a business that delivers products and services using the power of the Internet.
    Like any other business, it must have a product and in order to generate any income you are going to have to market it.
    This is where you have to choose what is it that you are most comfortable with, because options are endless.
    The beauty of this kind of business is that your initial investment is incomparably small related to what we call “Brick-and-Mortar” business: you do not have to rent an office, hire employees, buy any tools or machinery, rent a warehouse, maintain inventory ets. Plus you get to reach millions and millions of people via the Internet, which makes it much easier to actually achieve measurable resoults in a timely manner.
    The concept of an Internet based business is still new to a lot of people and you are going to here a lot of opinions like “It’s a scam” or “It’s to good to be true”, especially from your uncle Bob, who spent 20 years fixing furnaces and your aunt Polly, who spent her life working at the gas-station. It’s like with any other business opportunity: there is always a gun-slinger with his “It ain’t gonna work”. There are also a lot of people who is going to try to drag you into something scammy. They will be screaming “Sure, go ahead and join me, pay me this much money and then I will personally wright you a check for a million dollars!”
    And like with any other business you need a lot of information to make an educated decision about each particular business opportunity. What if you were interested in opening a laundromat, would you base your decision about getting involved on uncle Bob’s “It’s a get rich quick scheme” or on the sellers promise of a million dollars in a month? No. You would try to acquire all the information you can get and only based on facts you would make a conclusion about a particular business opportunity.
    As far as internet based business opportunities, look at following things:
    what is the product that you are going to market
    will a potential customer see the value of the product without a two hour presentation
    is there a clear marketing strategy
    is there a support or any kind of mentorship available
    what is the profit margin per unit of product (is it 20 cents per bottle of vitamins or $35000 per space shuttle).
    If you are able to locate those answers it should be relatively easy for you to make a disigion.
    Internet marketing is a great business after all and you would be surprised to know how many people are involved and what kind of money are being made here, but before you get involved, again, do your research.

    I can’t tell you that I’d investigated all the possible opportunities out there, but I stopped at one and haven’t regretted it so far.
    We have a lot of info about every aspect of what we do on our web site and it might be educational and helpful for you to check it out.
    http://www.oceaniswaiting.com

  • 21 SJohn // Jul 31, 2008 at 11:56 am

    I am very encouraged to hear from so many advocates of home based businesses, especially MLM and other internet-based businesses. Even at the womens networking groups I attend, I am very surprised to find that the majority of the women see business as only brick and mortar. I have a home-based accounting business that I started after the birth of my first child, and I love the flexibility. The only reason I would consider an outside office is for admin help and an internship program that I want to start in a few years. (Even then, I want to buy a building that houses other spaces for rental, so that my office expenses are basically covered, hence another business to run.) My husband and I also own a MLM business. I love the fact that this type of business does not come with the four biggest headaches: employees, inventory, accounts receivable and overhead! My thing is, I love my independence and I have always had entrepreneurship in my blood. I feel that if I enjoy it, I can make money at it somehow, especially nowadays. The internet does indeed open up the whole world to you. I also believe it is the great equalizer, since people seem to be less likely to be preoccupied with your ethnicity or gender or whether or not you are dressed! So my vote is for home-based.
  • 22 Broaraeagetry // Aug 3, 2008 at 7:51 am

    It’s amazing
  • 23 Fergie // Aug 5, 2008 at 5:57 pm

    I am looking at the old brick and mortar business. I’ve seen way too many business fail on the net, but just as many succeed.

    I think it’s a crap shoot. You decide what is best for you based on your capabilities and your desires as well as your financial situation and what you hope to earn. Internet isn’t for everyone just as a store isn’t for everyone. But to be successful you have to choose the one that you feel most comfortable in making a success!

  • 24 Allison // Aug 11, 2008 at 6:41 pm

    In my job as a horse trainer, obviously I can only do my work at a horse stable. However, with the internet so easy now to navigate, it makes selling client horses so much easier. I can video a horse’s workout, post it on YouTube, and reach potential buyers all over the nation, rather than the previous newspaper ads, endless phone calls, and buyers having to physically see the horse only to realize it is not at all what they were expecting, wasting their time and mine.

    I do have some acerage and an arena at home, and am in the process of re-modeling my barn and pastures to house more horses, so I can do more of my work from home as well. My overhead is much higher, but it goes into my home equity, so it’s not such a risk.

  • 25 Work At Home Mom Tara // Aug 13, 2008 at 8:52 am

    I would much rather have an online business. The online world opens the doors to millions of possible customers where in a brick and motor store, just your community.

Leave a Comment